Where Serious Collectors Come to Buy, Sell, and Protect Their Investment

Curated Vintage Sports Memorabilia for Sale — and Formal USPAP-Compliant Appraisal Reports for Insurance, Estate, and IRS Charitable Contribution Purposes

Featured on Sports Collectors Daily, WNEP-TV, and SPORTICO — ISA Accredited Member

Recently Added to the Collection

Wilson Official NFL Game Vintage Football – Date Code “DD” – 1971
$199.99

Wilson Official NFL Game Vintage Football – Game Code “DD” – 1971. New Laces and Bladder from Wilson. A Desireable Addition to any Sports Collection.

Please see Photographs. FREE SHIPPING.

Vintage Spalding Baseball - 1919-1924 - National League
$1,599.99

Offered is a vintage 1919–1924 Spalding National League baseball.

The ball is in very good condition and would present/display splendidly. It has two markings of roosters on the top. Red and black stitching is faded but discernible. Please see photographs.

FAST and FREE SHIPPING.

Early 1900's Baseball Catcher's Mask - Antique
$149.99

Early 1900's Baseball Catcher's Mask - Antique.

Goggle Eye catchers mask with Loop & Clip Construction. 

Possibly Youth or Small Adult.

Poor condition. No tags or labels visible.

Please See Photographs.

FAST and FREE SHIPPING.

Is Your Collection Properly Protected?

Most collectors significantly underinsure their vintage sports memorabilia — not because they don't care, but because they've never had a formal appraisal. A professional report establishes documented, defensible value for insurance coverage, estate planning, and IRS charitable contribution purposes.

Finding Nostalgia provides formal, USPAP-compliant appraisal reports prepared by an ISA Accredited Appraiser with a specialty in vintage sports memorabilia. Nationwide service available.

👉 Learn About Our Appraisal Services

Use the Contact Form below to reach out or call us at (272) 215 2483 for more information.